Skip to main content
← Projects

ICAI 3 - Review of UK Aid for Sustainable Cities

Citizen engagement towards UK aid on sustainable cities in Indonesia

Background

This review of UK aid support for sustainable cities examined the UK’s urban development portfolio from an environmental, social and economic perspective. It examined the extent to which the programme was delivering on the UK’s climate and sustainability objectives set out in UK strategy documents. The review gave the opportunity to build on previous ICAI work examining how UK aid was delivering on its climate and nature objectives, with a particular focus on cities – an area that had not yet received detailed attention from ICAI or other scrutiny bodies. SDG 11 was also the only remaining Goal to be addressed under ICAI’s Phase 3 Commission, aiming to make cities and communities ‘inclusive, safe, resilient and sustainable’ and calling for access for all to i) basic services; ii) energy; iii) housing; iv) transportation; and v) green public spaces.

The review covered aid programmes that were primarily focused on promoting sustainable cities, including programmes with a significant component on climate issues in urban settings. The review also provided an opportunity to examine coordination across a number of UK government departments involved in these thematic areas, including FCDO, DESNZ, DEFRA and DLUHC. In conducting this project, Dala’s team also collaborated with our esteemed colleague, Naufal Indriansyah Rofi as a Citizen Engagement Consultant.

Approach

The citizen engagement (CE) approach aimed to incorporate the voice of citizens in Indonesia into the UK aid reviews. This engagement aimed to involve directly and indirectly affected citizens or community groups in the discussions to hear directly from them to ensure that UK-government-funded programmes were needs-based, effective, and accountable. The CE contributed to answering questions on relevance and effectiveness: was UK support for urban programmes achieving its intended results for sustainable cities? Did it take into account national and local stakeholder priorities? Was it meeting needs? 

The CE gathered evidence of change affecting people affected by UK aid-funded interventions in selected programmes in the review’s proposed case study country, Indonesia, whether this was positive, negative, intended or unintended, direct or indirect.

  • Mewujudkan Kota Berkelanjutan: Suara dari Warga

    A sustainable city is not just about infrastructure—it is about who gets heard and who gets included. Dala Institute facilitated a community engagement to ensure the voices of diverse groups were heard in several UK Government supported projects related to sustainable cities in Indonesia, through a review conducted by Independent Commission for Aid Impact (ICAI) UK. Through this video, we hear directly from the people of Jakarta and Makassar: ride-hailing drivers, electric bus drivers, persons with disabilities, coastal communities, public transport users, and communities living in informal settlements to gather insights on several sustainable cities. They share their hopes, struggles, and lived realities in the face of change—from transport electrification to improving sanitation and neighborhood health. Because a just, inclusive city begins with those who live its challenges every day.

    View source page